Skip to main content

Nitto S83 v Thomson Elite seatpost



If you're looking for a high quality alloy seatpost then two that stand out are the Nitto S83 and the Thomson Elite. I own both, so how do they compare?

Looks
The S83 is a smooth, classic looking seatpost which is similar to road seatposts of a few decades ago. The Thomson has more of an industrial look, particularly with its textured machined surface. 

Versions
Thomson have loads of different versions available: in just about every combination of length and diameter you could want. The S83 is more limited, but if you like something a bit different you won't see so many of them out there on other bikes.

Weight
Thomson is a clear winner here. Depending on the exact version you get it's around 200 grams, which is pretty good for an alloy post. The Nitto is around 100 grams heavier.

Saddle clamp
The Thomson uses a tried and tested two bolt design which uses surprisingly small diameter bolts, but grips securely. The S83 uses large diameter bolts and is probably the most satisfyingly over-engineered design I've seen.

Price
Not much in it. Both these posts can be found for around £60 if you shop around online. There are far more places selling the Thomson so you’ve probably got more chance of a better deal on the Elite. Both these posts last well so eBay is another good place to look.

Noise
What? Well I think an important factor is that a bike runs silently. For me, the Thomson posts (I've tried a few) despite their great engineering, suffer from more creaks than other posts. I've tried different combinations of clamps, torque and lubricants and whilst it's not a huge issue it's enough to be annoying. Now Thomson sell a lot of posts and so I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who get on with them fine, but for me the creaks always come back. With the S83 I fitted it and forgot it, no problems, no creaks.

Verdict
There’s no bad choice here as these are both quality seatposts. The Thomson is the conventional choice and looks better on a modern bike, but if you fancy more of a retro look go for the Nitto.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Nitto S83 Seatpost Review

So, first things first: if you judge a seatpost by maximum lightness for minimum money then you might as well stop reading now, this isn't for you. However, if you're looking for a quality seatpost and weight is a secondary issue then read on. The S83 is a beautifully crafted piece of engineering that has a quality finish. It's a nice alternative to all the black carbon out there and looks particularly good on a steel or titanium bike. Most of the ones you'll find have got a silver finish, although black ones are available, you might need to search a bit on the internet and perhaps order directly from Japan. One issue that frustrates me with some seatposts is the poor quality of the saddle clamps, which can be flexy, with poor quality easily rounded bolts, often in the name of reducing weight. No such issues with the S83, which has large, high quality bolts that grip the saddle firmly. Both of the bolts are accessed from below making adjustment straig...
Post a Comment
Read more

Hope RS4 Open Pro Wheels Review

These days the likes of Mavic produce some really good wheels that do everything a set of handbuilts can and more, so is there really any good reason to get something built the old fashioned way? Well, a lot of it depends on what you really want to get from the wheels beyond things like weight and stiffness. Objectively, whilst most forum discussions on wheels will quickly get to someone suggesting "get some handbuilts mate", factory-built wheels do a perfectly good job and for a lot of people will be a good choice. There is, however, a certain satisfaction in a component put together by hand rather than in a factory, and handbuilt wheels are typically built with standard spokes and with more spokes per wheel which makes them easier to maintain. If you invest in wheels with good hubs they will typically outlast the rims which can then be replaced. This brings us to these Hope wheels, at the heart of which are the RS4 hubs. The Hubs Hope don't make things...
Post a Comment
Read more